went out on Thursday (of last week) for round 2. Now I'm shooting good. Decent grouping, hitting the nocks of the 1st or 2nd arrow putting them nearly touching. I took a nick out of the same vane of the same arrow as I did on Tuesday.
Then last Friday, we were shooting again. I was shooting the arrow with the nicked vane first and I then put a hole in a different vane on that same arrow.
A few shots later it happened...

...I Robin Hooded it.
* Also pictured is the buck (my first deer) from last year